Fabien Barthez and Phil Neville included in 'all

A debate around Manchester United's all-time XI has been sparked online after one selection included former goalkeeper Fabien Barthez and academy graduate Phil Neville

For the latest from the pitch sign up for our football newsletter

We have more newsletters

For the latest from the pitch sign up for our football newsletter

We have more newsletters

Manchester United fans were in shock after one supporter named Fabien Barthez and Phil Neville in their all-time XI.

Goalkeeper Barthez, who was on United's books from 2000 to 2004, and full-back Neville, who spent 11 years at the club after graduating from the academy, made a combined 520 appearances during their spells at Old Trafford.

However, neither set the world alight in Sir Alex Ferguson's side - especially compared to some of the world-class talent which did feature under the legendary Red Devils boss. So both being included in a best-ever United team raised plenty of eyebrows.

READ MORE: Man Utd didn't concede from penalty at home in 10 years - with only three against them

The selection from comedian Josh Jones for BBC's MOTDx was widely criticised on social media, with one person tweeting: "I never thought I’d see the day Philip Neville would be ahead of Patrice Evra or Denis Irwin. Less said about the goalkeeper situation the better."

Another questioned: "Barthez and Phil Neville has to be a joke right? I’d have De Gea ahead of that French madman let alone Edwin and Big Pete. As for LB I assume Denis Irwin and Patrice Evra played what golf?"

Who would make your all-time Man Utd XI? Let us know in the comments section.

"Left-back HAS to be Denis Irwin, and GK either Van der Sar or Schmeichel," argued a third, while a fourth wrote: "Barthez can never be ahead of Schmeichel, Van der Sar or De Gea."

A fifth commented: "I’ve never met anyone whose put Barthez ahead of Schmeichel/VDS and Phil Neville ahead of Irwin/Evra but each to their own."

And a sixth sarcastically quipped: "I mean, Barthez did win the World Cup? Speaking of which, where’s Kleberson in this list?"

The rest of Jones' team - which featured Phil's brother Gary, Rio Ferdinand and Steve Bruce in the heart of defence, a midfield four of David Beckham, Roy Keane, Paul Scholes and Cristiano Ronaldo, with Wayne Rooney and Eric Cantona up top - was widely accepted, however.